-
Who this checklist is for
-
Step 1: Verify the spec sheet against a real unit
-
Step 2: Test the numbers that matter on your floor
-
Step 3: Audit the safety certification — the whole system, not the platform
-
Step 4: Read the OEM / private label contract for firmware and branding control
-
Step 5: Evaluate wholesale and distributor support — not just product
-
Step 6: Request pilot data, not pilot promises
-
Step 7: Check the service pipeline — who fixes it at 2 a.m.
-
Common mistakes to avoid
Who this checklist is for
This is for the procurement, operations, or quality lead who's been handed a shortlist of AGV and AMR manufacturers and told to "pick one." You've already seen the brochures. What you need now is a way to tell a real manufacturing partner apart from a trading company with a good website (and, honestly, a lot of them are the latter).
I've been on the review side for four years. I run supplier qualification for an automation distributor — meaning I see every AGV, AMR, and autonomous forklift submission before it goes anywhere near a customer's floor. In 2024 I reviewed 63 first-time supplier packages and rejected 26 of them outright. Not because the products were bad, but because the documentation couldn't survive a basic audit.
Here are the seven steps I run every time. Work through them in order — each one filters out a certain type of vendor.
Step 1: Verify the spec sheet against a real unit
Don't accept the PDF. Ask for a video walkthrough of the exact model, filmed at the actual payload you need, with a tape measure or scale visible in frame. If they can't produce it in 72 hours, that tells you something.
It took me three years and about 150 supplier reviews to understand that the spec sheet is the least reliable document in the room. Payload numbers get rounded up. "Up to 1,500 kg" often means "1,500 kg on a perfectly flat floor, at 60% battery, with no attachments." Ask what the sustained payload is at 20% battery, on a 2% incline, with the standard fork carriage.
Checkpoint: Can the vendor show you a video of the unit meeting your spec — not a generic one?
Step 2: Test the numbers that matter on your floor
Every warehouse has three specs that kill AGV projects: floor flatness tolerance, aisle width, and charging window. Ask for the manufacturer's stated tolerance for each. Then ask what happens when your floor is 4mm off over 3 meters — because it probably is.
This is where a lot of AMR listings fall apart. The "no infrastructure" claim is true in a lab. On a floor with expansion joints and a slight crown, you're going to need fiducials or a full SLAM re-map. That's not a dealbreaker — it's a scope change you need to price before signing.
Checkpoint: Did the vendor ask about your floor plan and traffic flow before quoting?
Step 3: Audit the safety certification — the whole system, not the platform
"CE certified" on an AGV listing usually means the drive platform passed an EMC and low-voltage test. It does not mean the integrated system — with your top module, your conveyor, your safety scanner placement — meets ISO 3691-4 or ANSI/ITSDF B56.5. Those are system-level standards, and the integrator usually owns compliance, not the manufacturer.
Per FTC advertising guidance (ftc.gov), any safety or environmental claim in marketing has to be substantiated. So when a vendor says "SIL2 rated" or "CE certified," ask for the certificate number and the scope of the assessment. If they can't name the notified body, the claim is marketing, not compliance.
Checkpoint: Do you have the certificate number and the scope document — not just a logo?
Step 4: Read the OEM / private label contract for firmware and branding control
If you're evaluating a manufacturer for OEM or private label — and if you're a distributor, you are — this is the step where deals die. Ask three questions in writing:
- Who owns the firmware update pipeline, and can you push your own branded firmware?
- Can you rebrand the HMI, the companion app, and the fleet management software?
- What's the minimum order quantity (MOQ) for a custom colorway or logo, and does it reset annually?
Here's something vendors won't tell you: the OEM terms in the initial proposal are almost never the final terms. There's usually room on MOQ and on the exclusivity clause once you've proven you can move volume. But you have to ask — and you have to ask before the first PO.
Checkpoint: Is the firmware / branding control language in the contract, or only in the sales deck?
Step 5: Evaluate wholesale and distributor support — not just product
For agv system wholesale buyers, the product is half the deal. The other half is: spare parts lead time, training, and whether the manufacturer will co-sell with you or sell around you. Ask for the current lead time on the three most-replaced components (drive wheel, battery pack, safety scanner). Ask — point blank — whether the manufacturer sells direct in your territory.
Hikrobot, for example, positions itself around OEM / private label flexibility and a broad portfolio: Hikrobot AGV platforms for latent and towing work, Hikrobot AMR units for goods-to-person picking, plus autonomous forklifts and robotic picking cells. If you're evaluating them as an autonomous mobile robot manufacturer and wholesale partner, the questions in Steps 4 and 5 are the ones that matter most. The catalog breadth is real — but the channel terms are what determine whether the partnership works.
Checkpoint: Do you have a written spare-parts SLA and a territory map?
Step 6: Request pilot data, not pilot promises
"We'll do a free pilot" sounds generous. It usually means "we'll install a demo unit and call it a pilot." A real pilot has a defined scope: 30 days, X units, Y SKUs, measured uptime and pick rate against a baseline. Ask for the pilot report template before you agree to anything.
The subtle trap here is the denominator. A vendor will report "99.2% uptime" — over what period, with what definition of downtime? Ask for the raw log, not the summary. (You won't always get it. Ask anyway.)
Checkpoint: Is the success metric defined in writing before the pilot starts?
Step 7: Check the service pipeline — who fixes it at 2 a.m.
This is the step most first-time buyers skip, and it's the one that determines your total cost of ownership. Ask: who is the nearest authorized service tech, how many hours to site, and what's the remote diagnostic capability? If the answer is "we'll fly someone in," price that in — and then re-run the quote comparison with that number included.
Reviewing 200+ supplier packages annually has taught me one thing: the manufacturers that survive a second order are the ones whose service model was designed before the sales model. If the service org is an afterthought in the proposal, it'll be an afterthought on your floor.
Checkpoint: Do you have a named service contact and a response-time commitment?
Common mistakes to avoid
- Comparing quotes on unit price only. Integration, spares, and training costs usually exceed the hardware delta between vendors. Total cost of ownership (i.e., the number that actually matters) is rarely on the first page.
- Treating "CE" as a system certification. It's usually a platform-level mark. Confirm the scope.
- Skipping Step 4 because the sales rep said "we're flexible on OEM." Flexible in conversation is not the same as flexible in the contract. Get it in writing, with the MOQ and the exclusivity clause attached.
- Running the pilot before defining downtime. If you don't define it, the vendor will — favorably.
None of these steps is exotic. The reason they get skipped is that they slow down a deal everyone wants to close. But an informed buyer asks better questions and makes faster decisions — and in AGV procurement, the questions in Steps 3 through 5 are the ones that separate a three-year partnership from a one-year regret.